NFL QB Injury Crisis: Are Joe Burrow’s Cards Still Worth Collecting? (Dappz Up or Down)

Quarterbacks are driving headlines in the NFL — and not in a good way. With Joe Burrow out for months and stars like Jayden Daniels, Brock Purdy, JJ McCarthy, and Justin Fields already nursing injuries, collectors are asking a tough question: are their cards still worth it, or is it time to pivot?

That’s exactly what Dappz and Ethan dive into on this week’s episode of Up or Down, the show where they break down what really moves a card’s value up … or down.

Joe Burrow’s Injury History and Market Impact

Joe Burrow’s latest injury — a toe issue expected to sideline him for at least three months — feels like déjà vu for Bengals fans and card collectors. It’s the third time in six seasons he’s had his year derailed:

2020: Torn ACL, MCL, PCL, and meniscus (missed 6 games)
2023: Torn wrist ligament (missed 7 games)
2025: Toe injury (could miss remainder of the season)

The common thread? A shaky offensive line that continues to put the Bengals’ franchise QB in harm’s way. As ESPN recently reported, the Bengals will now have to navigate most of the season without their leader under center.

From a hobby perspective, it’s tough to justify Burrow’s card prices given his availability. His Prizm Silver PSA 10 rookie (pop 289) still sells for around $1,600, while comparable Jalen Hurts, Justin Herbert, and Jordan Love Silver PSA 10s go for roughly half that — in the $700–$800 range.

Is Burrow heading down the same path as Andrew Luck, another elite QB whose career (and card market) was cut short by constant injuries behind a weak offensive line?

Buy, Sell, or Hold?

This week’s show asks the question every collector is thinking: Would you buy Burrow at these prices, or shift your attention elsewhere?

While Burrow’s long-term value depends on his ability to stay on the field, the dips in his market could present opportunities — if you believe he can rebound. Meanwhile, other young QBs like Jordan Love and Jalen Hurts are offering more stability for a fraction of the cost.

What Am I Buying?

One of the best parts of Up or Down is the insider perspective from Ethan, who shares what top buyers in the hobby are looking for right now. This segment is always a fan favorite, giving collectors a peek at what’s moving in real time across eBay and other marketplaces.

The Bigger Conversation

Beyond the quarterback crisis, this week’s show also opens the door to a wider discussion about the state of the hobby. From the durability of modern stars to the long-term health of printing and supply in the trading card industry, it’s clear that football cards remain one of the most volatile — and exciting — sectors of the market.

Wrap Up

Thanks for joining another episode of Up or Down! Don’t forget to enter the weekly Ludex Loot Giveaway for your chance to win hobby prizes and add to your collection. Drop your thoughts in the comments — are you buying Burrow at today’s prices, or pivoting to another QB?

We’ll see you next week.

👉 For more hobby insights, check out our guide on The Best Cards to Look For in 2024 Panini One Football, a product featuring rookies like Bo Nix whose markets are also being shaped by on-field performance.